Ground elder and bindweed: an honest account
I have two weeds that frighten me more than any frost. Ground elder and bindweed both spread underground from pieces of white root, and both come back from fragments smaller than a fingernail. After two growing seasons of fighting them in the fruit borders, I can report some progress and one firm conclusion: there is no quick answer, only methods that work if you keep them up.
Knowing which is which
Ground elder has toothed leaves in groups of three and a smell like parsley gone wrong. Its roots are pale, brittle and shallow, mostly in the top 20 cm. Bindweed twines anticlockwise around anything upright, has arrow-shaped leaves, and its roots are thicker and can run down a metre or more. The shallower root of ground elder makes it the easier one.
Digging out
In autumn or early spring, when the soil is moist, I fork the bed over carefully rather than turning it with a spade, which chops the root into more pieces. Every white strand goes into a bucket and not on the compost heap. Bagged and left in the sun for a season, the roots rot down. Expect to repeat the job the next spring, with far fewer found each time.
Smothering
For a bed I can leave empty, a year of darkness works well. I cut the growth down to the ground in spring, laid overlapping cardboard, covered it with 15 cm of woodchip, and did not peek for twelve months. Light-excluding sheet does the same job, with the edges buried or weighted so nothing creeps through. Smothering ground elder works reliably. Bindweed is more stubborn and sometimes lifts the cover from underneath.
Weakening by cutting
Where I cannot clear a bed, I cut the tops off every time they reach about 15 cm, roughly every ten days in summer. The plant keeps using up its stored energy to regrow, and eventually it runs low. It takes two seasons of vigilance. Letting it flower and set leaf for even a few weeks resets the clock, so consistency matters more than effort.
Bindweed canes
I push a few bamboo canes into the ground where bindweed appears. It twines up them, and every few days I pull the vine, still attached to its root, free of the cane. Unwinding it from the base of a young shrub is fiddly, so I do it before the vines tangle in.
What did not work
Rotavating spread both weeds across the border. Mulching on top of live growth without cutting it first just gave them a cosy blanket. Mowing the grass margin each week, on the other hand, quietly beat the ground elder there within a year.
Realistic expectations
I am not going to be rid of them for good. What I aim for is reducing both to a handful of shoots a month, which can be pulled in a minute. Planting dense ground cover, such as comfrey or geraniums, over cleared soil closes the gaps they would otherwise take. Work out a method per bed, write the date you started on the gatepost, and be prepared for a long game.